
I was a little skeptical when I went to a free screening of
No Impact Man, the documentary about the guy who gave everything up in NYC for a year, documented it on a blog, and got a book deal. After watching the movie, however, I liked the guy more than I expected. But I also felt annoyed at times.
The highlight had to be a scene with an old-school gardener who taught No Impact Man (aka Colin Beaven) how to grow food. At one point he told Beaven that if he thought what he was doing was going to make any difference, he was either dishonest or delusional. Ha! He also said that if big business was actually threatened by Beaven's changes there's no way he'd be getting the sort of publicity he was getting. That's...kind of true. And depressing.
Which begs the question: what can one person do to actually make a difference then?
But at least I didn't walk away from the movie thinking the guy was a total wanker for "doing good" (temporarily) just for a book deal. Beaven acknowledged that he was totally naive when he began, and also realized that there are lots of people out there doing way more than he ever could -- and who aren't being all sensational and self-promoting about it, either. His intentions seemed more genuine than I expected.
Beaven even admitted during the audience Q&A that his approach to the media was all wrong. Early on, he had told Good Morning America that every person just has to do "one thing" to save the world, and now he admits that that won't be nearly enough. But it was kind of annoying to see him paraded out on TV shows on his bike like some kind of circus act. (Yes, people who ride bikes instead of driving cars, eat vegetarian diets, and compost are freaks...FREAKS!)
And as somebody -- I think his wife -- asked during the movie: is this "experiment" just going to make environmental activists look like wackos? Even more fringe? Instead of showing that these changes are something we all can do pretty easily in the mainstream.
His wife, Michelle, was definitely the highlight of the movie. The poor woman was TORTURED by her husband, but she played along. Beaven got rid of her cosmetics, made her stop drinking coffee, forced her to walk up nine flights of stairs to their apartment, made her ride a bike everywhere, washed her clothes with his feet in the bathtub...all for his fame & glory. And she went along in [mostly] good spirits. Her reactions throughout the "project" were pretty hilarious.
And I loved when she was talking about her experience as a bicyclist. She and Beaven were both yelling at drivers as they biked through the streets, which seemed pretty out of character for their easy-going personalities. Michelle admitted that as a driver she always got so angry at the bicyclists for taking "her" road, but now as a bicyclist she sees that the roads don't just belong to cars. A convert!
But I couldn't help but feel majorly annoyed when they had the baby conversation. Basically Michelle wanted a 2nd child, Beaven didn't, but he finally agreed to give it a try. What is up with people and kids? (And speaking of uh, no impact? Has anyone else seen stats on population trends and where we're going to be if people keep breeding at their current rates?) If you don't want a kid, like really, really want a kid, why are you just going to just agree to "give it a try." Yes, what the world needs is more people having more kids just for the hell of it or because they're having a mid-life crisis.
I understand it's necessary to compromise in relationships but when a kid is involved? Jesus.
But I definitely liked the movie and plan to get Beaven's book from the library.